Did a Late Night Ballot Dump Let Biden ‘Steal the Trump Landslide’?
A claim about Fairfax County, Virginia, lacks evidence.
| Khaya Himmelman | Feb 22 | 36 | 16 |
A widely shared article from Gateway Pundit questions the results of the 2020 presidential election in Fairfax County, Virginia. The Virginia Department of Elections certified the election results in favor of President Joe Biden on November 18, with Biden receiving 2,413,568 votes and Donald Trump receiving 1,962,430. More specifically, Biden received 419,943 votes in Fairfax County, while Trump received 168,401 votes, according to official election results from Fairfax County.
Despite the results of the election clearly in favor of Biden, the Gateway Pundit article claims that “they [Democrats] stole the election” through “the drop and roll” method. The alleged fraud, as described by Gateway Pundit was carried out as follows: The drop refers to stealing the election by dumping a “massive number of tens of thousands of unexplained votes.” The second part, allegedly, is “the roll,” which is described as fixing “the remaining vote count in proportions to keep the lead.”
So, in the case of Fairfax County, the article claims that there were “308,000 votes dumped for Biden in [sic] middle of the night.” The article then points to election results from the Virginia Secretary of State’s Office, calling the results “interesting,” without pointing out what is unusual or “interesting” about the results.
According to the Virginia Department of Elections, Biden received 69.89 percent of the votes in Fairfax County and Trump received 28.03 percent of the votes. The article, however, cites a spreadsheet, the origins of which are unknown, that claims without the alleged “ballot dump” Biden would have received only 111,536 votes and Trump would have received 89,029 votes.
It’s unclear where this 308,000 number comes from. The only election reporting issue in Fairfax County was a spreadsheet data entry error posted on the Fairfax County Office on Election Night that was quickly corrected. The data entry error led to Biden getting an additional 100,000 votes, until it was corrected.
Gary Scott, general registrar and director of elections for Fairfax County, explained the error via email to The Dispatch Fact Check: “On the night of the last election, there was a data entry error posted on the Fairfax County Office of Elections website. The error was quickly identified and removed within 15 minutes. The information was reviewed and the correct numbers were then posted. The incorrect numbers were only posted on the public facing website, which reports unofficial results. The incorrect results were never entered into the Virginia Department of Elections database and only the accurate numbers were submitted.”
Scott also addressed this specific “ballot dump” claim calling it “baseless.” He added that Virginia’s election results have not been disputed by a reputable source: “This claim is baseless and came out of the blue to us,” said Scott. “The results reported by our office to the Virginia Department of Elections were certified by them and have been undisputed by any reputable group.”
If you have a claim you would like to see us fact check, please send us an email at factcheck@thedispatch.com. If you would like to suggest a correction to this piece or any other Dispatch article, please email corrections@thedispatch.com.
| 36 | 16 |
With all respect, this is a perfect example of the fake fact-check genre that is itself a form of disinformation. I think this site should aspire to do better. Here's my beef:
1. It doesn't clearly define the actual "fact" being checked. Lots of things are discussed and characterized loosely, but the factual assertion at issue appears to be: "that there were '308,000 votes dumped for Biden in [sic] middle of the night.'”
2. This could be easily checked by consulting the Edison Data. But you don't do that. Instead, you just say that from the article "It’s unclear where this 308,000 number comes from," as if that proves the number is incorrect.
3. You talk about some 100,000 vote error that was corrected. But that has nothing to do with whether the 308K number is right. So that's a red herring. Why are you talking about it?
4. You cite the statement of "Gary Scott, general registrar and director of elections for Fairfax County" that "This claim is baseless." But that assertion itself is "baseless," because it literally has no stated basis in fact. Besides, the guy in charge of running the election is never in a million years going to say "yeah, the results could be totally fake." Another red herring.
And that's it. You never presented any evidence that disproved the "'308,000 votes dumped" claim. And yet you claim you have "debunked" this fact. This is weak.
That everyone in the comments is impressed by this "fact check" sophistry shows how effective it is as a form of propaganda.
I have, for my sins, been trying to actually follow all the 'evidence' of election rigging, in order to keep an on open mind. It's difficult and dispiriting and I'm very grateful that you guys have professionals on it!
This is a very good example of its kind though. Here's a claim that is very specific in the described outrage ("308,000 dumped votes"). Fun name that's easy to remember and to repeat ("Drop and roll!"). Very, veeeery thin on sources ("An article said so!"). Very short on vital implementation details ("How was the dump done? Aren't all votes compared against the voter rolls? How can the ballots be "unexplained"? They're either from unique registered names/addresses or they're not. If they have the power to magic up 300,000 seemingly legit ballots, somehow without any duplicates in the voter roll, why would they need Dominion to cheat the machines count? Why would they even need to roll? How on earth does one even do the roll? If "they" have the power to "fix the remaining vote at a particular proportion," why do they even need to do a drop? Who are "they" exactly?)
And very ... weird ... in implication. Am I reading you right that, even if you take 308,000 off of Biden's total in that county, he would still have beaten Trump 111,538 - 89,029? Are they claiming a massive fraud that didn't actually change the outcome? Just ... so.... confused.